‘Cobra Kai’ creators say it was ‘disappointing’ Hilary Swank didn’t return

The creators of Netflix’s Cobra Kai managed to pack in an impressive amount of Karate Kid Easter eggs in the show’s final season, but there was one major callback they weren’t able to make happen: an appearance from The Next Karate Kid‘s Julie Pierce, played in the 1994 film by future Oscar winner Hilary Swank.

It wasn’t for lack of trying. Knowing how much fans wanted Julie to show up — and being huge fans of the Karate Kid franchise themselves — Cobra Kai creators Josh Heald, Jon Huwitz, and Hayden Schlossberg began outreach to Swank’s representatives in the lead-up to the show’s sixth and final season.

“We did reach out in the very early days before the season to see if there was a path [for her to appear],” explains Heald. “We had an inkling of an idea about how she could come into this story and not have to commit to 10 episodes or something. It was going to feel like it could be a one- or two-episode arc, similar to what we did with Elisabeth Shue, where you can bring Ali back in at a pivotal moment and affect an important relationship.”

Armed with what Heald calls “the beginnings of a genesis of an idea,” he, Hurwitz, and Schlossberg reached out to Swank’s team “to find out if we could have a discussion with her about it and introduce ourselves.”

That approach has worked before, not only on Oscar-winner Shue, who reprised her role as Ali — who dumped Johnny (William Zabka) for Daniel (Ralph Macchio) in the original Karate Kid — in Cobra Kai season 3. Heald, Hurwitz, and Schlossberg also brought back Yuji Okumoto (Karate Kid Part II antagonist Chozen Toguchi), Sean Kanan (Karate Kid Part III villain Mike Barnes), Thomas Ian Griffith (Part III‘s big bad, Terry Silver), Robyn Lively (whose Jessica from KKIII turned out to be the cousin of Daniel’s wife, Amanda, played by Courteney Henggeler!), and many more.

Unfortunately, the conversation with Swank never happened.

“On her end, it was very respectful, but we never got that opportunity to sit down and pour our heart out the way that we typically do when we bring back characters from the legacy,” Heald says. “She was just in a place where she wasn’t looking to do that. She had had babies. I think she was in production on something at the time, and it was a respectful pass on even the idea of a meeting. She didn’t want us to go through the trouble of flying out to her and putting our heart on the sleeve because it just wasn’t something she was ready to do at that moment.”

Sign up for Entertainment Weekly‘s free daily newsletter to get breaking TV news, exclusive first looks, recaps, reviews, interviews with your favorite stars, and more.

But Cobra Kai never dies — and neither do the creators’ hopes about a possible visit from Julie Pierce in a future Miyagi-verse project someday. (The trio is already at work on potential Cobra Kai spinoffs.)

“It’s a big piece of the Miyagi-verse that’s still out there,” says Heald. “For us, it was a little disappointing because we like getting everybody, but at the same time, we didn’t sacrifice any huge story that we had fully developed. It’s more fruit on the vine for if we can revisit this universe going forward.”